The only advice I would ever give is to never take advice.
If you listen to others you are statistically listening to mediocracy.
AI as an instrument is causing massive disruptions into what is valuable and what is not.
If progress in LLMs stopped right now forever, there would still be a decade of unrealized efficiency gains in the economy. Now imagine how much value is unrealized with progress in LLMs growing. It’s time to be an entrepreneur
Philosophy: I Need It@philosophyineedit·Divergence80
The sentence "What's YOUR contrarian truth?" is a contradiction in terms, as truth, by definition, isn't dependent on any particular person. The truth is objective, and no matter how many words or how strong my appeal to your emotion will be, it will not make it true or false.
the more you know about one thing the easier it becomes to see everything through it
we spend our lives becoming experts in one way of thinking and then try to explain the entire world with it
but the world isn’t divided into disciplines
the most interesting discoveries often
The only reason it's important for most humans to continue to have jobs is so that they don't get bored and cause crime. Only a extremely small percentage of people really make a difference.
It's fine if most humans' brains are being rotted by social media/AI/common vices out because it makes it easier for me to win and get what I want. As long as the people that I care about are well off and competent, it doesn't matter what happens to the rest of them.
A Short Essay on Names: Today, September 29, the president of the United States, Donald J. Trump, issued an executive order directing the U.S. government to replace “artificial intelligence” (AI) with “super intelligence” (SI) in official communications and other non-statutory documents.
Without proper context, this seems patently absurd and certainly not something a president should be doing. I will try to convince you otherwise.
To create a word is to name a thing.
Language can be understood in this way: names for things, objects, experiences, relationships, pasts, and possible futures we have learned to recognize. Naming makes a distinction, available to ourselves and others about how the world has been disclosed to us. Once something has a name, we can point to it together, discuss it, fight about it, remember it, and organize around it. A new word gives us a new subject or object of shared attention. It gives an It it’s It’sness.
Kabbalah, which has understood this for millenia, takes this even further.
In the thought developed by Rabbi Shneur Zalman of Liadi, the founder of Chabad Hassidut: he says that the Names of things in lashon hakodesh, the sacred Hebrew language, the language of the Old Testament, and the Language that God proverbially used to “speak” reality into existence, these Divine Names contain the Divine Essence that actually sustains the thing being named within its spatiotemporal existence.
In Genesis 1:3–26, the creation narrative of the cosmos unfolds through God’s “Speech”, as He “Speaks” forth light, establishes the firmament, gathers the waters to reveal dry land, and “Speaks” of vegetation, heavenly lights, animals, and Mankind. The Bible could have continued using the word it had used in it’s first verse, the Hebrew בָּרָ֣א, Create, to continue describing the narrative of the Creation of our Cosmos. Instead it uses וַיֹּ֥אמֶר, And He Said. God “Speaks” and things are turned into Things. The Divine Ontology is Spoken into Being.
In Kabbalah, where an ordinary word identifies something by human naming, the Sacred Wordname, the Logos, is understood to participate in what that thing actually is.
It has also been described by Kabbalists as the language that was spoken by Adam in the Garden of Eden, before the fall. The primordial “Adamic” Language, the Language of God.
“The pen is mightier than the sword.” The pen determines whom the sword is raised against. Take names such as God, prophet, or even Freedom: people have staked their lives, killed, and have been killed over what these names mean and who is allowed to authorize their meaning.
Even our language about God requires extraordinary care. Maimonides spent an enormous amount of time in his Moreh Nevuchim distinguishing names derived from divine actions (God’s “Hand” or God’s “Anger” from God’s unique proper, and True name.
Words and Names help us direct attention but just as easily can help us commit the darkest atrocities. As they can help reveal the world to ourselves, they can also participate in a great concealment.
Imagine a world without language. No words and no names. There would still be sensations and things all around us which we would be capable of recognizing at some level. But how much of our shared world would remain available to us? A language allows an internally experienced thing, feeling, or sensation to become something that can be examined together, within a social world. One could even make the extraordinary claim that consciousness itself is made up of language or letters, as the Kabbalists describe, Prima Materia itself being made up of the 22 Hebrew letters. Well, what is consciousness? We experience consciousness as thoughts and sensations. How are thoughts thunk or sensations revealed in description if not through Language.
Gravity comes from the Latin gravitas, meaning weight or heaviness. Newton gave an old name new signification: the force that could make an apple fall also holds the moon in orbit. Once that relationship could be reformulated, named and mathematically described, it could also be learned, taught, tested, and used to predict the path of a rocket. This is what naming makes possible.
Sometimes speech also helps bring a reality into being. A promise can create a future obligation. An Official proclamation or declarative statement-for example, the U.S. Declaration of Independence-can help establish a new political entity.
The Zohar, the 13th-century Kabbalistic masterpiece makes a far more radical claim about sacred interpretation: a new discovery, (in Hebrew: חִדּוּשׁ), in Torah creates a new heaven. The Kabbalists then apply this beyond strictly torah study, human innovation, within the Zoharic account, can participate in creation. Science can be thought of as Man self-performing Revelation by naming truer and truer theories of Reality, Reality being that way in which God has manifested himself in our world.
We need not accept the entirety of Kabbalistic metaphysics to recognize something of it in ordinary life. The words through which we explain our world are inherently deterministic and play a central role in the world we subsequently build. Peter Thiel, in a 2015 conversation with Tyler Cowen, makes a surprising observation about startups: “A slight aesthetic thing I believe in very strongly is the names of companies are often very predictive of future failure or success.” He goes on to contrast the name PayPal and it’s seeming friendliness with the negative associations he heard in Napster, “you nap some music, you nap a kid” and Airbnb’s innocence with Uber’s “It sounds like a bad name from Germany sometime in the 1930s, what are you exactly above? Maybe the law?” (Uber was in the midst of intense regulatory scrutiny at the time with some believing they would not make it out alive). His argument was that a name can pre-disclose and possibly predispose a company’s character and influence and how the public and then regulators view it. A name tells something to you about a thing long before the thing itself is actually encountered.
Return, then, to artificial intelligence. Artificial comes from the Latin artificialis, referring to art or skilled making. Its origin may not be an insult, but words accumulate meaning drag and drift: artificial came to suggest imitation, insincerity, and something that is not genuine. An artificial smile is something suspect. I believe that calling this technology “artificial” encourages a similar suspicion, making it easier to regard the technology as a counterfeit or an unwarranted and unwanted intrusion. In my view, this disposition makes prohibitive regulation more likely, strangling benefits and possibilities we have scarcely begun to imagine.
Super comes from the Latin for above, over, or beyond. In ordinary English it also expresses admiration. In my mind, superintelligence directs attention toward enlarged capacities, hints to discoveries we could not make unaided, diseases we will learn to cure, and infinite possibilities beyond our present reach. Superiority can sound threatening, but Thiel’s own example of the negative superiority he was hearing in Uber did not end up affecting the company in the long run as it seems he was suggesting it might.
I believe SI offers a more correct and confident starting point for thinking about what we might accomplish with these technologies. This is not an essay arguing for the finality of the name Super Intelligence, or SI, but as a name for the futures we might hope to build, I prefer it. Trump, as Onomastician-in-Chief, has made the right decision.
I honestly don’t want to read anything that’s written by AI if someone is claiming for it to be them. Like it’s fine if edits or explains something but I don’t really care it’s impersonating and people are pretending for it to be their thoughts.
The only thing that will survive the AI revolution is: specialized high tech compute, software will be commoditized, and only currency is action.
*not investment advice*
@maude·Divergence80
glad you challenged. people can also not listen to my advice. I recognize there is in importance for us to pass down knowledge and we even see this value through technology allowing us to compress more info into less and transfer it easier allows our world to progress (addressing why we should teach our baby things still).
Yes humans are the middle layer between AI and the diffusion into operating systems. humans' resistance to change, delays the realized effects of AI's integration with ops.
yes to build a culture around challenging the norms to bring substance to beliefs. Rather than challenge to "preform". Theres only substance to being contrarian if its grounded in earned reason.
yes in "machivelli the prince" there is fake court hearing after fake court hearing to make it look like overthrowing kings is just. -- another form of media propaganda in a sense. question is how can we see past the optics of these thingsl
Kind of what I said here. There’s a definition and substance, like proposition and correspondence
Attached
@maude· Oct 21Divergence 76
You can’t ‘lose’ friends. Your definition of friends might change over time, but what’s never lost is a connection between definition and substance.
even more so they need GPU's but alice huang might have all of them now
At the peak you master the world of school. After you create and grow your own worlds (maybe in the form of companies). The ultimate progression would be to then create a world so big it dominates the world.
Diverge is only for outside consensus ideas
Level of work of across BC students is High. But the location that energy is being invested is largely going to developing existing worlds (that I think its relevance will expire), rather than creating new ones
I see everyone "working so hard" at Boston College, but they're working underneath a world that they don't own. Their byproducts go to a transcript that go to a job application that go to sitting at a desk listening to orders. They don't own where their energy is going and who it benefits.
if we all breathe and move everyday, we might as well have our movements build towards something that scales beyond us
Especially bc AI can be an expert at one thing, but it can't create connections across disciplines as well as we can
They didn't know what they wanted at 18, and they likely still don't know what they want at 38. They've never used their mind to choose and evaluate for themselves, but rather, they fall to follow and conform to the beliefs in warm proximity to them.
people work, but inside other people's lives. they must continue in their predictable loop & follow path of least resistance, as they have been trained to do so their entire lives.
exactly what I said here.
Samay your natural divergence is refreshing. I agree all the money should go to making ai better or making things ai cant do better. In that case more data centers and more diverge centers
@maude·Divergence80
insane depth of thought here. I also think about how language compresses emotions, associations, etc. Changing a world also allows us to ditch the old emotional representation/ association we had with an idea. I also think about my name and how everyday I change what it means to be associated with maude niemann as a label.
Attached
@maude· Oct 3Divergence 89
To elevate your life, you must elevate the definition of the words around you. Two people can use the same exact language to describe their day: they eat healthy, exercise well, work hard, and are focused with their work. And what their life really looks like may look completely different.
You need to out run yourself
There should always be an agenda in everything. That just means we are living intentionally
Machiavelli says depart from the orders of others
Life is to diverge.
I run every red light on my e-bike.
I am always doing a different pose than what my hot yoga instructor ques
Whoever your conformist friend is, they sound like pollution. What computers really are is a way for you to put any world in front of your eyes without traveling physical distance. I can read infinite books on my computer and learn infinite material. Your definition of living life might be trolling around with your conformist furries.
The substance of the surroundings tell me exactly who I am. But memorizing materials for my exam is not who I am. It his hard to morph my cells to fit into the wrong world of studying when my eyes are consumed by the right world
Filler words like “honestly, like, & really” dilute the substance of your post.
GMOs taste so good because its effects manifest in us godly figures enabled with power to orchestrate the poisoned dolls below us
Make a site people want to use
When government tells people what to do, people are trained to following & repeating (eventually all converge on the same answer). Instead, when individuals are empowered to choose, they are forced to develop their own beliefs and ways of living, allowing their highest level of uniqueness of individuality to emerge.
I will never allow myself to wake up feeling that fat again
Exactly. Our biology always pushes to a purpose, first the purpose could be feeling "safe", than that could be creating a unique impact & have your individuality be "seen".
A real human does not do repetitive tasks & spend time on whats already been done, thats what AI does. I agree with learning architecture to define the best direction, but why build/execute the app with your own two hands when AI can do the repetitive execution, allowing your mental energy to be used for novel tasks.
Action in the wrong direction has no currency. Divergent directional thinking will be the currency and left as the only thing AI cant do